Epitope-dependent avidity thresholds for cytotoxic T-lymphocyte clearance of virus-infected cells

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are crucial for immune control of viral infections. "Functional avidity," defined by the sensitizing dose of exogenously added epitope yielding half-maximal CTL triggering against uninfected target cells (SD(50)), has been utilized extensively as a measure of antiviral efficiency. However, CTLs recognize infected cells via endogenously produced epitopes, and the relationship of SD(50) to antiviral activity has never been directly revealed. We elucidate this relationship by comparing CTL killing of cells infected with panels of epitope-variant viruses to the corresponding SD(50) for the variant epitopes. This reveals a steeply sigmoid relationship between avidity and infected cell killing, with avidity thresholds (defined as the SD(50) required for CTL to achieve 50% efficiency of infected cell killing [KE(50)]), below which infected cell killing rapidly drops to none and above which killing efficiency rapidly plateaus. Three CTL clones recognizing the same viral epitope show the same KE(50) despite differential recognition of individual epitope variants, while CTLs recognizing another epitope show a 10-fold-higher KE(50), demonstrating epitope dependence of KE(50). Finally, the ability of CTLs to suppress viral replication depends on the same threshold KE(50). Thus, defining KE(50) values is required to interpret the significance of functional avidity measurements and predict CTL efficacy against virus-infected cells in pathogenesis and vaccine studies.