Statistical reviewing for disability and rehabilitation

Area of Science:

• Statistical methodology in scientific publishing
• Manuscript review process optimization

Background:

• The challenge of 'getting past the statistical referee' is a long-standing issue in academic journals.
• Ensuring robust statistical practices is crucial for scientific integrity and publication acceptance.

Purpose of the Study:

• To assist authors in navigating the statistical review process effectively.
• To enhance the statistical credibility of scientific journals.

Main Methods:

• A reflection on 20 years of experience in statistical reviewing for academic journals.
• Literature review to support statistical best practices.

Main Results:

• A comprehensive list of statistical criteria that authors should address in their manuscripts.
• Emphasis on recognizing general statistical problems rather than requiring expert-level mastery.

Conclusions:

• Authors equipped with these criteria will be better prepared to handle statistical issues during manuscript submission.
• Improved understanding of statistical requirements can lead to smoother publication pathways.