Related Experiment Video
Updated: Apr 8, 2026

Nasal Potential Difference to Quantify Trans-epithelial Ion Transport in Mice
Published on: July 4, 2018
[NaCl 0.9 % for volume substitution : blessing or curse?]
1Medizinische Klinik D, Abteilung für Allg. Innere Medizin, Nephrologie und Rheumatologie, Universitätsklinikum Münster, Albert-Schweitzer-Campus 1, 48149, Münster, Deutschland, philipp.kuempers@ukmuenster.de.
This review examines the use of 0.9% saline for volume substitution in clinical settings. Evidence suggests that its high chloride content may lead to hyperchloremic acidosis and worsen outcomes in surgical and critically ill patients. Balanced crystalloids appear to be safer alternatives. The authors highlight the lack of data supporting 0.9% saline and recommend updated guidelines. In-house training is suggested as a tool to raise awareness and promote change in clinical practice.
Area of Science:
- Clinical fluid therapy
- Renal physiology in critical care
- Surgical outcomes research
Background:
Current clinical practice often relies on 0.9% saline as a standard for volume substitution. However, recent findings challenge this approach due to its high chloride content. Prior research has shown that 0.9% saline can cause hyperchloremic acidosis in healthy individuals. This condition may impair renal perfusion and lead to complications. No prior work had resolved whether these effects translate to clinical outcomes in patients. Recent studies suggest that 0.9% saline may worsen outcomes in surgical and critically ill patients. This gap motivated a closer examination of its effects compared to balanced crystalloids. The need to reassess standard practices is now evident based on emerging evidence.
Purpose Of The Study:
This review aims to evaluate the clinical impact of 0.9% saline in volume substitution. The focus is on its effects in surgical and critically ill patients. The study seeks to identify whether high chloride content contributes to adverse outcomes. It also investigates whether balanced crystalloids offer a safer alternative. The motivation stems from the lack of evidence supporting 0.9% saline as a superior choice. The review highlights the importance of reevaluating current guidelines. The goal is to inform clinical decisions based on recent findings. The study emphasizes the need for updated training and alternative strategies.
Main Methods:
The review approach involves analyzing recent clinical studies on 0.9% saline. It synthesizes evidence from published trials comparing saline to balanced crystalloids. The authors examine outcomes such as acute kidney injury and mortality rates. They assess the physiological effects of hyperchloremic acidosis in surgical patients. The literature is evaluated for consistency in findings across different populations. The review also considers the impact on patients with preexisting renal conditions. In-house training programs are discussed as a tool for awareness and behavior change. The synthesis focuses on evidence-based implications for clinical practice.
Main Results:
The strongest finding is that 0.9% saline increases the risk of acute kidney injury. Studies show a higher need for renal replacement therapy in saline-treated patients. Postoperative in-hospital mortality is also elevated in saline users. No data support the superiority of 0.9% saline over balanced crystalloids. The high chloride content is linked to hyperchloremic acidosis and reduced renal perfusion. These effects are observed even in patients with hypokalemia or kidney injury. Balanced crystalloids appear to avoid these complications. The review concludes that current guidelines may not reflect the latest evidence.
Conclusions:
The authors propose that 0.9% saline may not be the optimal choice for volume substitution. They suggest that balanced crystalloids could offer safer alternatives in clinical settings. The review highlights the need for updated guidelines based on recent evidence. The findings suggest that 0.9% saline may worsen outcomes in surgical and critical care. No prior work had resolved the lack of data supporting its use. The authors emphasize the importance of in-house training for medical staff. They propose that awareness and education can drive sustainable changes in practice. The review calls for further investigation into alternative fluid strategies.
Frequently Asked Questions
The main outcome is an increased risk of acute kidney injury and higher postoperative mortality.
0.9% saline has a nonphysiological high chloride content, while balanced crystalloids have lower chloride levels.
Hyperchloremic acidosis may rapidly reduce renal perfusion and contribute to acute kidney injury.
In-house training raises awareness among medical staff and promotes alternative fluid strategies.
Recent studies suggest balanced crystalloids reduce complications like acute kidney injury.
The authors propose that guidelines should be updated to reflect the lack of evidence supporting 0.9% saline.
Related Concept Videos
Reactions of α-Halocarbonyl Compounds: Nucleophilic Substitution
SN1 Reaction: Kinetics
However, Sir Christopher Ingold and Edward D. Hughes, who studied the kinetics of various nucleophilic substitution reactions, noticed that a tertiary alkyl halide does undergo a nucleophilic substitution reaction in the presence of a weak nucleophile. While studying the substitution...
Pharmaceutical Alternatives: Stability-Related Therapeutic Nonequivalence
Nucleophilic Substitution Reactions
In 1896, the German chemist Paul Walden discovered that he could interconvert pure enantiomeric (+) and (-) malic acids through a series of reactions. This conversion suggested the involvement of optical inversion during the substitution reaction. Further, in 1930, Sir Christopher Ingold described for the first time two different forms of nucleophilic substitution reactions, which are known as SN1 (nucleophilic substitution unimolecular) and SN2 (nucleophilic substitution...
SN2 Reaction: Kinetics
In a chemical reaction, a relationship exists between the concentration of reactants and the rate at which the reaction proceeds. The study to measure this relationship is known as the kinetics of a chemical reaction. Kinetic studies are used to deduce the rate law of a chemical reaction, which provides information about the species involved during the transition state of the rate-determining step. Thus, kinetic studies help to derive the mechanism of a...
Nucleophilic Acyl Substitution of Carboxylic Acid Derivatives

