Repeatability of intraoperative Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensing in cataract surgery

To evaluate the repeatability of aphakic intraoperative wavefront aberrometry and compare it with preoperative and postoperative aberrometry.

Department of Ophthalmology, Hanusch Hospital, Vienna, Austria.

Prospective case series.

Patients scheduled for cataract surgery were each measured 3 consecutive times using Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensing (HS-WFS) preoperatively, intraoperatively in aphakia, and 2 months postoperatively after intraocular lens implantation by a single examiner. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) of spherical equivalent (SE) values were evaluated for each timepoint. Intrasubject standard deviation (Sw) as repeatability (Sr) with corresponding repeatability limit () and mean SE differences with corresponding limits of agreement (LoA) were calculated for comparison.

A high consistency of repeated measurements was found with ICCs above 0.9 for each of the 3 timepoints. Intraobserver repeatability (Sr) and repeatability limit (r) of intraoperative aberrometry SE measurements (30 eyes of 30 patients) were 0.34 diopters (D) and 0.95 D, respectively. The LoA for intraoperative aphakic SE across 3 consecutive measurements were -0.71 to +0.85 D. For comparison, Sr and r for phakic preoperative measurements in the cataractous state (30 eyes of 30 patients) and postoperative measurements in the pseudophakic state (24 eyes of 24 patients) were 0.33 D and 0.93 D and 0.23 D and 0.64 D, respectively. Similarly, the LoA for preoperative and postoperative SE measurements were -0.66 to +0.60 D and -0.27 to +0.45 D, respectively.

HS-WFS test-retest reliability was high for all 3 timepoints, but the intraoperative setting resulted in a lower repeatability and broadened the agreement range.