Organ preservation surgery for pyriform sinus carcinoma with vocal cord fixation: functional and oncological outcomes

Pyriform sinus carcinoma with vocal cord fixation is stratified as stage T3 and above, and non-surgical treatment is generally preferred according to the guidelines, aiming to preserve laryngeal function. However, long-term survival is often compromised by deep infiltration of the tumor. Vertical hemipharyngolaryngectomy (VHPL) was previously reported to be a feasible surgical approach for organ preservation. The aim of this study was to evaluate the functional and oncological outcomes of VHPL in patients.

Patients who underwent VHPL type II (total VHPL, which includes the removal of a vertical section of the thyroid cartilage through the anterior commissure to the upper border of the cricoid cartilage) for pyriform sinus cancer with vocal cord fixation at the authors' institute between 1999 and 2015 were retrospectively analyzed. Functional outcomes concerning swallowing and decannulation were evaluated. Successful functional preservation was defined as laryngeal preservation as well as oral realimentation and decannulation within 6 months after surgery. The oncological outcomes were measured by overall survival (OS) and disease-free survival (DFS) with Kaplan-Meier curves and comparisons were performed between the VHPL-treated patients and patients who underwent non-surgical treatment within the same period.

A total of 23 patients (stage T3, 17 patients; stage T4, 6 patients) whose initial treatment was VHPL type II were studied, and a cohort of 123 patients was selected as the control group. Pedicle and free flap reconstructions were performed on 12 and 11 patients, respectively. Postoperative radiation and chemoradiation was performed on 14 and 3 patients, respectively. Flap failure and pharyngeal fistula were detected in 2 and 5 patients, respectively. Oral realimentation and decannulation within 6 months were achieved in 82.6% (19 patients) and 87.0% (20 patients) of patients, respectively, and the total functional preservation rate of the study cohort at 6 months was similar to that of the control cohort. (78.3% vs. 82.9%, p = 0.28). After a median follow-up period of 49 months, 9 recurrences and 8 deaths had occurred in the study cohort. According to the Kaplan-Meier analysis, the study cohort had superior DFS (5-year DFS 60.3% vs. 44.6%, p = 0.04) and similar OS (5-year OS 63.8% vs 57.0% p = 0.28) compared with those in the control group.

VHPL yielded favorable oncological and functional outcomes in patients with unilateral pyriform sinus carcinoma and vocal cord fixation.