[The occurrence and evaluation methods of horizontal semicircular canal dysfunction in patients with common...

Objective:To understand the occurrence of horizontal semicircular canal functional impairment in patients with common vestibular diseases and to explore the characteristics and clinical value of different evaluation methods of horizontal semicircular canal. Methods:From July 2013 to December 2016, patients who attended the vertigo clinic of the First Affiliated Hospital of Dalian Medical University and completed more than three horizontal semicircular canal function tests were retrospectively analyzed. A total of 396 patients diagnosed as vestibular migraine （VM）, Ménière's disease （MD）, benign paroxysmal positional vertigo （BPPV）, vestibular neuritis （VN） and 104 patients with unknown diagnosis were enrolled. The results of caloric test （CT）, rotation test （RT）, head-shaking nystagmus test （HSN） and video head impulse test （vHIT） were collected and the abnormal detection rates of different detection methods were calculated. The sensitivity, specificity and coincidence rate of various detection methods were statistically analyzed using CT as the gold standard. Results:①The abnormal rates of the four evaluation methods from high to low were HSN, CT, RT, vHIT （51.20%, 50.80%, 25.76%, 19.74%, respectively）; ②Taking CT as the gold standard, among these four common vestibular diseases, the sensitivity and specificity of vHIT were 0.13-0.41 and 0.69-1.00, the sensitivity and specificity of HSN were 0.44-0.76 and 0.29-0.69, and the sensitivity and specificity of RT were 0.25-0.45 and 0.50-0.84;③According to statistical analysis, only HSN and CT results showed no statistically significant difference in the 4 diseases. There was no significant difference between RT and CT in VM and BPPV, and vHIT and CT in BPPV. Conclusion:The abnormal rate of HSN results in common vestibular diseases is highest, and it could be recommended as a routine vestibular function screening item. The specificity of vHIT is highest and worthy of promotion. CT is still an irreplaceable method to evaluate the function of horizontal semicircular canal.