On two tests of fit for HLA data with no double blanks

Stevens suggests a test of fit, based on Bernstein's estimators, of the Hardy-Weinberg law for the ABO system. Nam and Gart extend this test to the generalized ABO-like system and apply it to HLA data. When the recessive gene is rare, Huether and Murphy recall Haldane's point that its Bernstein's estimator is negatively biased and go on to suggest novel corrected versions of it. With the identification of more HLA antigens, it is not uncommon to find, in certain populations, that the sample data contain no double blanks; that is, every individual reacts to at least one antigen for a given locus. Gart and Nam give a simple score test of a zero true recessive-gene frequency for such situations. Here we examine the extended test of Stevens as a test of this hypothesis. We find that it is fully efficient for two codominant alleles but that when the number exceeds two its efficiency may be 50% or lower or as high as 100%, depending on the number of alleles and the pattern of gene frequencies. The tests are applied to a set of HLA data.