Vanishing of Black Hole Tidal Love Numbers from Scattering Amplitudes

We extract the black hole (BH) static tidal deformability coefficients (Love numbers) and their spin-0 and spin-1 analogs by comparing on-shell amplitudes for fields to scatter off a spinning BH in the worldline effective field theory and in general relativity. We point out that the general relativity amplitudes due to tidal effects originate entirely from the BH potential region. Thus, they can be separated from gravitational nonlinearities in the wave region, whose proper treatment requires higher order effective field theory loop calculations. In particular, the elastic scattering in the near field approximation is produced exclusively by tidal effects. We find this contribution to vanish identically, which implies that the static Love numbers of Kerr BHs are zero for all types of perturbations. We also reproduce the known behavior of scalar Love numbers for higher-dimensional BHs. Our results are manifestly gauge invariant and coordinate independent, thereby providing a valuable consistency check for the commonly used off-shell methods.