Mn²⁺ vs Co²⁺ substitution into β-TCP: Structural details and bone cells response

This work investigated the range of substitution of two biologically relevant ions, namely Mn²⁺ and Co²⁺, into the structure of β-tricalcium phosphate, as well as their influence on bone cells response. To this aim, β-TCP was synthesized by solid state reaction in the presence of increasing amount of the substituent ions. The results of the X-ray diffraction analysis reveal that just limited amounts of these ions can enter into the β-TCP structure: 15 at% and 20 at% for cobalt and manganese, respectively. Substitution provokes aggregation of the micrometric particles and reduction of the lattice constants. In particular, the dimension of the c-parameter exhibits a discontinuity at about 10 at% for both cations, although with different trend. Moreover, Rietveld refinement demonstrates a clear preference of both manganese and cobalt for the octahedral site (V). The influence of these ions on cell response was tested on osteoblast, osteoclast and endothelial cells. The results indicate that the presence of manganese promotes a good osteoblast viability, significantly enhances the expression of osteoblast key genes and the angiogenic process of endothelial cells, while inhibiting osteoclast resorption. At variance, osteoblast viability appears reduced in the presence of Co samples, on which osteoblast genes reach higher expression than on β-TCP just in a few cases. On the other hand, the results clearly show that cobalt significantly stimulates the angiogenic process and inhibits osteoclast resorption.