Does the timing of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery affect flexion contracture formation in rats?

Anterior cruciate ligament injuries are commonly treated with ligament reconstruction surgery, but post-operative joint contracture is a major complication. The optimal timing for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction remains controversial, with some clinical studies suggesting that early surgery may increase the risk of joint contractures, while others have found no such association. To clarify this, we investigated the effects of the timing of reconstruction surgery on contracture formation using a rat model.

Anterior cruciate ligament-transected rats were divided into groups based on the timing of reconstruction: immediate, early, and delayed (1, 14, and 28 days after transection, respectively). Some anterior cruciate ligament-transected rats did not receive reconstruction surgery. Untreated rats served as controls. At 56 days after ligament transection, we assessed knee extension range of motion before (including both myogenic and arthrogenic factors) and after myotomy (arthrogenic factor only), as well as fibrotic changes in the joint capsule.

Anterior cruciate ligament transection alone significantly decreased range of motion before myotomy, but not after myotomy. In all reconstructed groups, both range of motions before and after myotomy were significantly reduced compared to the control, indicating the induction of arthrogenic contracture by reconstruction surgery. Fibrotic changes in the joint capsule were observed in all reconstructed groups, contributing to arthrogenic contracture formation. However, the timing of reconstruction had no effect on range of motions and fibrotic changes in the joint capsule.

Our findings may help guide clinical decision-making regarding the timing of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery.