Sectored single-energy volumetric-modulated proton arc therapy (VPAT): A preliminary multi-disease-site concept study

To explore the feasibility of a novel intensity-modulated proton arc technique that uses a single-energy beam from the cyclotron. The beam energy is externally modulated at each gantry angle by a tertiary energy modulator (EM). We hypothesize that irradiating in an arc without requiring an energy change from the cyclotron will achieve a faster delivery (main advantage of our technique) while keeping clinically desirable dosimetric results.

In a retrospective cohort of four patients with female pelvis, prostate, lung, and brain cancers, we investigated our volumetric-modulated proton arc therapy (VPAT) technique. Arcs were simulated by sectors of 1°-spaced static beams. Keeping the energy requested from the cyclotron the same for each entire arc was supported by a predesigned EM placed in front of the nozzle. As a feasibility measure, EM thicknesses were calculated. Delivery times and doses to targets and organs at risk (OARs) were compared to those of the clinical plans.

VPAT plans were comparable to their clinical counterparts in achieving target dose conformity, being robust to uncertainties, and meeting clinical dose-volume constraints. Cyclotron energies for the four cases were within 159-220 MeV, and energy modulation range was 69-100 MeV, equivalent to 13-19 cm of water-equivalent thickness (WET). Plan delivery times were reduced from > 5 min in our clinical practice to < 3.5 min in VPAT.

For the evaluated plans, the novel VPAT approach achieved shorter delivery times without sacrificing robustness, OAR sparing or target coverage. VPAT's EMs had WETs implementable in a clinical setup.