Prevalence and Characteristics of Transsphincteric Anal Fistulas Unclassifiable by the Sumikoshi Classification: A...

The Sumikoshi classification for anal fistulas is widely used in Japan; however, it does not include a category for transsphincteric fistulas. Therefore, low transsphincteric fistulas were included in type IIL (low intersphincteric) for convenience; however, high transsphincteric fistulas have not been properly classified. We defined high transsphincteric fistulas as type IIT and investigated their prevalence and clinical characteristics.

Consecutive patients who underwent fistula surgery at our hospital were included. The operative and endoanal ultrasonography records were retrospectively reviewed, and the following cases were reclassified as type IIT: cases documented as transsphincteric fistulas or cases with written records and/or illustrations indicating that the fistula tract penetrated the upper two-thirds of the external anal sphincter.

Of the 1,069 eligible patients, 895 (83.7%) had type II (intersphincteric) fistulas. Among the type II subtypes, type IIL was the most common with 771 (86.1%) patients, whereas type IIT accounted for 54 (6.0%) patients. The direction of the primary opening was more posterior (62.2%) in patients with type II fistulas other than type IIT, but it was more anterolateral (55.6%) in patients with type IIT fistulas. Patients with type IIT fistulas were more likely to undergo sphincter-sparing surgery than patients with other type II fistulas (37.0 vs. 3.7%, p<0.001).

Type IIT is not rare (6.0%) and should be treated as a complex fistula because of the greater involvement of the external anal sphincter. Surgeons may benefit by including type IIT as a new type II subclass in the Sumikoshi classification system.