A Comprehensive Review of Numerical and Machine Learning Approaches for Predicting Concrete Properties: From Fresh to...

The growing demand for innovation and the use of diverse materials in cementitious composites necessitate predictive models that account for material variability. Numerical, code-based, and machine learning (ML) models have been developed to predict various concrete properties. However, their accuracy is significantly influenced by factors such as mix design, composition, intrinsic properties, and external conditions. Developing robust models that integrate these variables is essential for improving predictive accuracy and optimizing material performance. This paper presents a comprehensive review of numerical, code-based, and ML modelling techniques for predicting both fresh and long-term concrete properties. Since both numerical and ML models rely on experimental data-either to determine coefficients in numerical approaches or to train ML models-data gathering, preprocessing, and handling are crucial for model performance. Previous studies indicated that data variability significantly impacts accuracy, emphasizing the importance of effective preprocessing. While larger datasets generally improve reliability, some models achieve high accuracy even with very limited data. This review not only demonstrates the superior performance of ML models over traditional numerical approaches but also highlights the relative effectiveness of different ML algorithms based on reported accuracy metrics. ML-based approaches, including both ensemble and non-ensemble models, have exhibited strong predictive capabilities across a wide range of concrete property categories. In contrast, traditional numerical models often yield lower accuracy, although modified versions that incorporate additional parameters have shown improved performance. Furthermore, the integration of optimization algorithms and interpretability tools enhances both predictive reliability and model transparency-critical aspects that are often overlooked.