A Quantitative Indicator-Based Framework for Sustainability-Driven Selection of Conventional and Smart Materials in...

The transition towards sustainable cities requires material selection strategies capable of balancing environmental, economic and social performance while accounting for the emerging functionalities offered by smart materials. This work proposes a sustainability-driven methodology based on normalized multi-dimensional indicators for the objective comparison of functionally equivalent conventional and smart materials in the built environment and demonstrates its application through the parametric design of an urban bench. The quantitative assessment showed substantial differences among the investigated materials: Shape Memory Polymers (SMPs) resulted in a panel mass of 5 kg, CO₂ emissions of 2.4 kg CO₂/kg, and embodied energy of 37 MJ/kg, compared with 32 kg, 13 kg CO₂/kg, and 260 MJ/kg for NiTi, and 40 kg, 15 kg CO₂/kg, and 320 MJ/kg for magnetic Shape Memory Alloys, respectively. Finite element analysis further demonstrated the influence of structural design, with the maximum principal stress decreasing from approximately 0.073 MPa at a panel thickness of 10 mm to 0.015 MPa at 50 mm, corresponding to a reduction of approximately 79%. The results demonstrate that smart materials do not inherently represent more sustainable alternatives than conventional materials; rather, their adoption should be justified when their adaptive functionalities provide measurable benefits capable of compensating for their environmental and economic burdens. The proposed framework provides a practical decision-support tool that shifts material selection from property-driven choices toward function-oriented, sustainability-based design, supporting more informed decisions for next-generation urban infrastructure.