Mental imagery ability is associated with visual working memory performance: evidence from aphantasic participants

Visual imagery refers to the mental generation of visual representations of stimuli, while visual working memory involves retaining visual information for a short period without external input. Due to the conceptual overlap between these two constructs, successful performance on visual working memory tasks may rely on the use of visual imagery to rehearse items during the retention interval. Consequently, individuals with aphantasia, who lack voluntary visual imagery, may experience difficulties with such tasks. However, prior research has suggested that some individuals with aphantasia might employ non-visual strategies to compensate for this deficit. In two experiments, we examined visual working memory performance in aphantasic and control participants across a range of stimulus types. In Experiment 1, participants completed a change localization task using color squares and complex fractals; in Experiment 2, stimuli included real words, phonologically valid pseudowords, and phonologically invalid pseudowords. Across both experiments, aphantasic participants demonstrated significantly impaired visual working memory compared to controls. Notably, their performance was equally impaired for stimuli that were easily verbalizable (i.e., colors and words) and those that were not (i.e., fractals and pseudowords). Furthermore, individual differences in visual imagery ability, as measured by the Vividness of Visual Imagery Questionnaire (VVIQ), significantly predicted working memory performance across all stimulus types. Finally, aphantasics accessed verbal materials quicker than controls from working memory, with no speed difference for visual materials. These findings provide evidence that visual imagery may be needed to support visual working memory.