The significance of specific distributions and functions in models of quantitative inheritance

The main purpose of this paper is to attract attention to the fact that a mathematical model of quantitative inheritance can lead to qualitatively different results, if distributions and functions which in the model represent biological processes are assumed to take analytically different (even though qualitatively similar) forms. A simple model of the effect of environmental variation on the post-selection genotypic variance in a population under phenotypic stabilizing selection is considered. It is demonstrated that this model leads to qualitatively different conclusions depending on whether the phenotypic fitness function is assumed in a Gaussian or in a quadratic form.