Related Experiment Videos
Measles reporting completeness during a community-wide epidemic in inner-city Los Angeles
D P Ewert1, S Westman, P D Frederick
1Communicable Disease Control Unit, Los Angeles County Department of Health Services.
Abstract:
A study was undertaken to determine the extent of measles underreporting among preschool-age children. In two community surveys conducted in inner-city Los Angeles during 1990 and 1991, respondents were asked whether preschool-age children in their households had ever been ill with measles. Information about measles episodes was obtained and medical records were reviewed, when available. A probable measles case was defined as having 3 or more days of rash with fever of 38.3 degrees centigrade or greater, and either cough, coryza, or conjunctivitis. To determine the proportion of cases reported, probable measles cases identified were matched with measles cases reported to the Los Angeles County Department of Health Services. Of the 947 children ages 6 weeks through 59 months included in the surveys, 35 children had experienced an illness episode which met the probable measles case definition. Ten (29 percent) of the 35 probable measles cases were reported to the health department. Hospitals reported 9 (69 percent) of 13 probable measles cases evaluated while private physicians' offices reported 0 (0 percent) of 12 evaluated (Fisher's exact test, P < 0.001), although 5 children were seen by private physicians before rash onset. Reporting was more complete for cases occurring during 1990 and 1991 (33 percent) than from 1987 through 1989 (18 percent). The hospitalization rate for preschool-age children with probable measles cases in the catchment area was estimated to be 8 percent (95 percent confidence interval = 0 to 18 percent). Although measles is a serious communicable disease which is almost completely preventable, cases of it among preschool-age children in this high incidence area were substantially underreported,especially by private physicians. Due to reporting bias, reported measles cases were representative of more severe cases than all the cases that occurred.
Insights
Measles cases in preschool children were significantly underreported, especially by private doctors. This study highlights the need for better measles surveillance in high-incidence areas.
Area of Science:
- Epidemiology
- Public Health
- Infectious Diseases
Background:
- Measles is a highly contagious and preventable disease.
- Accurate reporting is crucial for effective disease surveillance and control.
- Underreporting of measles cases can lead to biased estimates of disease severity and incidence.
Purpose of the Study:
- To determine the extent of measles underreporting among preschool-age children in inner-city Los Angeles.
- To compare the reporting rates of probable measles cases identified through community surveys with those reported to health authorities.
- To identify potential sources of reporting bias, particularly concerning healthcare providers.
Main Methods:
- Two community surveys were conducted in Los Angeles during 1990-1991.
- Respondents provided information on measles episodes in preschool-age children.
- Probable measles cases were defined and matched with health department records; medical records were reviewed when available.
Main Results:
- Of 35 probable measles cases in children (6 weeks-59 months), only 10 (29%) were reported to the health department.
- Hospitals reported 69% of evaluated cases, while private physicians reported 0% of evaluated cases.
- Reporting was higher for recent cases (1990-1991, 33%) compared to earlier cases (1987-1989, 18%).
Conclusions:
- Measles cases among preschool-age children in this high-incidence area were substantially underreported.
- Private physicians played a significant role in the underreporting of measles cases.
- Reported measles cases may represent more severe instances, leading to biased surveillance data.