Ablation of remaining functioning thyroid lobe with radioiodine after hemithyroidectomy for carcinoma

Nineteen patients who had hemithyroidectomy as a surgical procedure for thyroid cancer were given radioiodine to ablate the residual hemithyroid. Two different protocols were used, with either a larger single dose or multiple smaller doses. Ablation was achieved in 28% with the single large dose approach and in 33% of patients given split doses of similar total amount. This response to the initial attempt at eradication of the residual normal hemithyroid is considerably lower than the accepted ablation rate with comparable doses administered to patients with small thyroid residues after total thyroidectomy. It is suggested that the effect of radioiodine treatment may relate inversely to the size of the thyroid remnant. Our findings also are in support of the surgical approach advocating total thyroidectomy for patients contemplating ablation of thyroid residues after surgery for thyroid carcinoma.