Factors determining the outcome of scaling and root planing

Scaling and root planing are the predominant and recognized forms of periodontal therapy. They have been known for centuries, and have been investigated with increasing intensity since the turn of the century. Scaling and root planing aim at therapeutic changes of the "hard tissue lesion" at the root surface, in order to render it biologically acceptable to cells capable of attaching to it. Two major components of these root surface alterations are calculus and cementum alterations. Numerous studies have shown that scaling and root planing effectively removes subgingival deposits, and that this removal is seldom complete in deeper pockets. Even though beneficial clinical effects of scaling and root planing have been shown, it is unlikely that the full potential of healing is utilized today due to technical shortcomings. Several studies have shown that the design and dimensions of curets as used today are not optimal. These instruments are for many situations too big, subject to rapid dulling, and produce a smear layer. Chemical agents have been used to remove this layer with limited success. The therapist is a virtually unknown factor in the system of delivering scaling and root planing. A recent study showed that scaling and root planing forces used by different therapists on similar root surfaces varied by factors greater than 10. In addition, higher forces were shown to remove significantly more root substance. Apparently there is a large subjective component included in the delivery of scaling and root planing therapy. Even though scaling and root planing have been shown to be effective therapeutic procedures, many aspects require more research.