Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jun 27, 2026
08:51
Coulomb Explosion Imaging as a Tool to Distinguish Between Stereoisomers
Published on: August 18, 2017
When Huygens and Mariotte agree
1University of Alaska, Department of Mathematics 6660, Fairbanks, Alaska 99775-6660, USA. ffwrt@uaf.edu
Applied Optics
|November 28, 2008
Summary
Seventeenth-century scientists Edme Mariotte and Christiaan Huygens proposed different theories for atmospheric halos. This article explains how their seemingly incompatible ideas about ice prisms and spheres/cylinders align for common halo predictions.
Area of Science:
- Atmospheric optics
- Optical phenomena
- Meteorological optics
Background:
- Historical scientific theories on halo formation.
- Seventeenth-century explanations for atmospheric optical phenomena.
- Edme Mariotte's ice prism theory.
- Christiaan Huygens' sphere/cylinder theory.
Purpose of the Study:
- To reconcile seemingly contradictory historical theories of halo formation.
- To explain the agreement between Mariotte's and Huygens' predictions for common halos.
- To provide a unified understanding of early halo theories.
Main Methods:
- Comparative analysis of historical scientific theories.
- Theoretical physics principles applied to optics.
- Geometric analysis of light interaction with prisms and spheres/cylinders.
Main Results:
- Demonstration of how ice prisms and spheres/cylinders can produce similar halo patterns.
- Identification of specific conditions under which both theories yield comparable predictions.
- Explanation of the geometric and optical reasons for the convergence of the two models.
Conclusions:
- Mariotte's and Huygens' theories, though different, are reconcilable for common halo phenomena.
- The apparent incompatibility of early halo theories can be resolved through detailed optical analysis.
- Understanding historical scientific discourse enhances our knowledge of atmospheric optics.
Related Concept Videos
01:18Saint-Venant's Principle
The principle of Saint-Venant postulates that the stress distribution within a structural member does not rely on the precise method of load application except in the vicinity of the load application points. Consider a scenario where loads are centrally applied on two plates. In this case, the plates move toward each other without any rotation. This movement causes the member to contract in length and expand in width and thickness. Uniform deformation across all elements and maintaining...
03:40Hess's Law
There are two ways to determine the amount of heat involved in a chemical change: measure it experimentally, or calculate it from other experimentally determined enthalpy changes. Some reactions are difficult, if not impossible, to investigate and make accurate measurements for experimentally. And even when a reaction is not hard to perform or measure, it is convenient to be able to determine the heat involved in a reaction without having to perform an experiment.
01:28Equivalent Couples
In mechanical engineering, the concept of equivalent couples plays a crucial role in understanding and analyzing various mechanical systems.
Two couples are considered to be equivalent if they produce the same rotational effect on a rigid body. In other words, the two couples have the same magnitude and act in the same direction, causing the same angular displacement or acceleration in the body.
For instance, consider two couples lying in the plane of the page, with one having a pair of equal...
Two couples are considered to be equivalent if they produce the same rotational effect on a rigid body. In other words, the two couples have the same magnitude and act in the same direction, causing the same angular displacement or acceleration in the body.
For instance, consider two couples lying in the plane of the page, with one having a pair of equal...
01:26Hooke's Law
Hooke's law, a pivotal principle in material science, establishes that the strain a material undergoes is directly proportional to the applied stress, defined by a factor called the modulus of elasticity or Young's modulus.
01:28Cartesian Vector Notation
Cartesian vector notation is a valuable tool in mechanical engineering for representing vectors in three-dimensional space, performing vector operations such as determining the gradient, divergence, and curl, and expressing physical quantities such as the displacement, velocity, acceleration, and force. By using Cartesian vector notation, engineers can more easily analyze and solve problems in various areas of mechanical engineering, including dynamics, kinematics, and fluid mechanics. This...
01:16Perpendicular-Axis Theorem
The perpendicular-axis theorem states that the moment of inertia of a planar object about an axis perpendicular to its plane is equal to the sum of the moments of inertia about two mutually perpendicular concurrent axes lying in the plane of the body.
Consider a circular disc of mass M and radius R lying along an x-y plane. The origin lies at the center of the disc, and the z-axis is perpendicular to the disc's plane. All three axes coincide at the disc's center. The moment of inertia of this...
Consider a circular disc of mass M and radius R lying along an x-y plane. The origin lies at the center of the disc, and the z-axis is perpendicular to the disc's plane. All three axes coincide at the disc's center. The moment of inertia of this...