Related Experiment Video
Updated: Dec 8, 2025
Method of Studying Palatal Fusion using Static Organ Culture
Published on: September 19, 2015
The Method of Surgical Lip Repair Affects Speech Outcomes in Children With Bilateral Cleft Lip and Palate
Holly Peryer1, Rona Slator1, Jenny Thomson2
1West Midlands Cleft Lip and Palate Centre, 156630Birmingham Children's Hospital, Birmingham, United Kingdom.
Objective:
It was hypothesized that lip repair protocols in children with bilateral cleft lip and palate (BCLP) would affect development of bilabial consonants /m/ /b/ /p/. This study compared speech outcomes in 2 surgical groups.
Design:
A retrospective case note investigation.
Setting:
UK Cleft Centre (2000-2009).
Patients:
Forty-nine children with complete BCLP, of whom 26 had a 1-stage and 23 a 2-stage bilateral cleft lip repair.
Interventions:
One-stage cleft lip repair versus a 2-staged cleft lip repair.
Main Outcome Measures:
Bilabial consonant production at 18 months, 3 and 5 years of age. Cleft Speech Characteristics (CSCs) at age 5.
Results:
At age 18 months, 81% of the 1-stage lip repair group and 4% of the 2-stage lip repair group produced bilabial consonants (P <·0001, Fisher test). At age 3 years, 81% of the 1-stage and 26% of the 2-stage lip repair groups produced bilabial consonants (P =·0133, Fisher test). At age 5 years, both groups had similar bilabial consonant production, but children in the 2-stage lip repair group had more frequent and severe CSCs (P = ·0037, χ2).
Conclusion:
A 1-stage lip repair for children with complete BCLP resulted in better bilabial consonant production at 18 months and 3 years of age than a 2-stage lip repair. At age 5 years both groups had bilabial consonants but children in the 2-stage lip repair group had worse CSCs. The surgical protocol for bilateral cleft lip repair affected speech outcome in children with BCLP.
