Chimeric Viruses Containing Select Agents: The Biology Behind Their Creation, Attenuation, and Exclusion From...

The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), as part of the Federal Select Agent Program, and under the purview of 42 CFR §73.3, has the ability to regulate chimeric viruses that contain portions of pathogens that are part of the select agents and toxins list. In addition, the CDC is responsible for excluding pathogens from regulation, including chimeric viruses, that are sufficiently attenuated. Since 2003, the CDC has excluded over 20 chimeric viruses that contain portions of select agents. But in late 2021, the CDC proposed a regulatory first-the addition of a chimeric virus to the select agents and toxins list. To better understand the importance and applicability of this action, we surveyed the landscape of previous exclusions from select agent regulation. First, we reviewed the exclusion criteria used by the Intragovernmental Select Agents and Toxins Technical Advisory Committee in their advisement of the Federal Select Agent Program. We then reviewed the literature on chimeric viruses that contain portions of select agents and that have been excluded from regulation due to sufficient attenuation, focusing on chimeric alphaviruses and chimeric avian influenza viruses. By analyzing biological commonalities and patterns in the structure and methodology of the development of previously excluded chimeric viruses, we provide insight into how the CDC has used exclusion criteria in the past to regulate chimeric viruses. We conclude by contrasting previous exclusions with the recent addition of SARS-CoV-1/SARS-CoV-2 chimeric viruses to the select agents and toxins list, demonstrating that this addition strays from established, effective regulatory processes, and is thus a regulatory misstep.