Diagnostic validity of ICDAS clinical criteria on digital 3D models

To assess the diagnostic validity of ICDAS clinical criteria on 3D dental models from intraoral scanning.

This is a retrospective analysis on part of the baseline sample collected in a cohort study and included 73 participants (12-19 years) from Denmark and Greece. The assessment was made by visual inspection, and then by visual inspection associated with radiographs. All participants were scanned with TRIOS 4 which uses white light to obtain the 3D models with tooth color, as well as blue light source (415 nm) for fluorescence. The 3D models' evaluation was conducted using tooth-color texture and subsequently fluorescence. Two scores were obtained for the 3D model examination: i) ICDAS based on tooth-color information; ii) ICDAS based on tooth-color information supplemented with fluorescence. For the analysis, weighted kappa, sensitivity (SE), specificity (SP) and accuracy (ACC) were calculated.

Regarding all lesions the values for SE, SP, and ACC were respectively 0.804, 0.801, and 0.802 for tooth-color, and 0.819, 0.808, and 0.810 for tooth-color supplemented with fluorescence. In terms of accuracy parameters for moderate-extensive lesions, the values for SE, SP, and ACC for tooth color were 0.709, 0.948, and 0.944, while for fluorescence they were 0.815, 0.937, and 0.934.

Caries assessment with ICDAS criteria on 3D dental models produces reliable scores. Visual caries analysis using 3D models demonstrates commendable diagnostic accuracy and reasonable consistency with traditional methods. The use of intraoral scanners may be beneficial in evaluating occlusal caries.

The importance of this study is to prove the diagnostic accuracy of caries lesions diagnosis made using and intraoral scanner and to offer greater confidence to professionals who use this diagnosis tool in their daily clinical practice. Intraoral scanners demonstrate to be an accurate tool for diagnosing occlusal caries.