Mapping Guaranteed Positive Secret Key Rates for Continuous Variable Quantum Key Distribution

The standard way to measure the performance of existing continuous variable quantum key distribution (CVQKD) protocols is by using the achievable secret key rate (SKR) with respect to one parameter while keeping all other parameters constant. However, this atomistic method requires many individual parameter analyses while overlooking the co-dependence of other parameters. In this work, a numerical tool is developed for comparing different CVQKD protocols while taking into account the simultaneous effects of multiple CVQKD parameters on the capability of protocols to produce positive SKRs. Using the transmittance, excess noise, and modulation amplitude parameter space, regions of positive SKR are identified to compare three discrete modulated (DM) CVQKD protocols. The results show that the M-QAM protocol outperforms the M-APSK and M-PSK protocols and that there is a non-linear increase in the capability to produce positive SKRs as the number of coherent states used for a protocol increases. The tool developed is beneficial for choosing the optimum protocol in unstable channels, such as free space, where the transmittance and excess noise fluctuate, providing a more holistic assessment of a protocol's capability to produce positive SKRs.