Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jun 4, 2025
Handheld Metal Detector Screening for Metallic Foreign Body Ingestion in Children
Published on: September 11, 2018
Implementation of a Child Maltreatment Screening Tool in the Prehospital Setting
Makenzie Ferguson1, Shelley Brukman1, Kim Zaky1,2
1Department of Emergency Medicine, Children's Hospital of Orange County (CHOC Children's), Orange, California.
Insights
Emergency medical services (EMS) clinicians can now use the Shield tool to screen for child maltreatment in the prehospital setting. This new screening aid was well-integrated and accepted by EMS clinicians, showing potential for standardized child abuse detection.
Area of Science:
- Emergency Medicine
- Pediatrics
- Public Health
Background:
- Emergency medical services (EMS) clinicians are uniquely positioned to identify child maltreatment due to their frequent encounters with children in home environments.
- Existing child maltreatment screening tools are primarily designed for primary care and emergency departments, with a gap in prehospital settings.
- EMS training on recognizing child maltreatment signs is often insufficient, highlighting the need for specialized tools.
Purpose of the Study:
- To develop, implement, and evaluate the effectiveness and acceptability of a prehospital child maltreatment screening tool.
- To adapt an existing screening tool (P-CAST) for use in the prehospital environment.
- To assess the integration and usability of the screening tool within the EMS electronic patient care report (ePCR) system.
Main Methods:
- A mixed-methods study combining qualitative and quantitative data collection from June 2021 to June 2022.
- Development of the "Shield" screening tool by adapting the Pittsburgh Child Abuse Screening Tool (P-CAST).
- Integration of Shield into the ePCR system for three participating fire agencies, with subsequent data collection and clinician feedback via surveys and focus groups.
Main Results:
- Shield screenings were initiated on 948 out of 1,054 eligible pediatric patients (<15 years old) and completed on 753.
- 3.4% (32 patients) screened positive for findings concerning for maltreatment.
- Post-implementation focus groups indicated that EMS clinicians found Shield to be well-integrated into their ePCR workflow.
Conclusions:
- The Shield screening tool was initiated in nearly 90% of evaluated pediatric patients, demonstrating high potential for adoption.
- The tool shows promise in standardizing child maltreatment screening within the prehospital setting.
- The positive feedback from EMS clinicians suggests good acceptability and feasibility for routine use.
Objectives:
Emergency medical services (EMS) clinicians are in a unique position to screen for child maltreatment as they are often the first point of contact with the health care system and they may encounter children in their home environment. However, EMS training regarding the signs of child maltreatment is lacking. Although several child maltreatment screening tools have been developed for the primary care and emergency department (ED) settings, there appears to be no published literature describing or evaluating a prehospital screening aid. The objective of this study was to develop, implement, and examine the effectiveness and acceptability of a prehospital child maltreatment screening tool.
Methods:
We completed a mixed methods qualitative and quantitative study, with data collection spanning June 2021-June 2022. We developed a child maltreatment screening tool "Shield" for the prehospital setting by adapting Pittsburgh Child Abuse Screening Tool (P-CAST), a screening tool developed at the University of Pittsburgh for use in the ED. Shield was integrated into the EMS electronic patient care report (ePCR) for three participating fire agencies. Data, including demographics, ED evaluation, and outcomes, were collected for patients who underwent Shield evaluation. The EMS clinicians completed self-assessment surveys and participated in focus groups to provide feedback on their experience using Shield.
Results:
Participating EMS agencies evaluated 1,054 eligible patients (children <15 years old) during the study period, June 2021-June 2022. Of these, Shield screenings were initiated on 948 patients and completed on 753. Among all patients for whom a Shield evaluation was started, 32 (3.4%) screened positive for findings and/or histories concerning for possible maltreatment. Of these, 20 patients were transported to the primary study institution; in the ED 10 patients underwent additional child maltreatment evaluation. Pre-implementation surveys suggested a majority (77.2%) of EMS clinicians desired a child abuse screening tool integrated into the ePCR and post-implementation focus group data demonstrated EMS clinicians found Shield to be well integrated into their ePCR.
Conclusions:
Shield screens were initiated on nearly 90% of pediatric patients evaluated by EMS during the study period, suggesting that this tool has the potential to help standardize child maltreatment screening in the prehospital setting.
