Related Experiment Videos
When is a voluntary commitment really voluntary?
1New York Hospital.
The American Journal of Orthopsychiatry
|January 1, 1977
Summary
Cognitive disorganization impairs voluntary action, potentially leading to misclassification of psychotic patients as voluntary hospital admissions. Alternative categories beyond voluntary and involuntary are proposed to prevent misuse.
Area of Science:
- Psychiatry
- Cognitive Neuroscience
- Legal Medicine
Background:
- Voluntary hospitalization requires patient comprehension and intent.
- Cognitive disorganization, common in psychosis, affects attention and understanding.
- Current legal frameworks may misinterpret non-comprehending behavior.
Observation:
- Patients with cognitive disorganization may comply with hospitalization without true voluntary consent.
- Clinicians might incorrectly perceive this compliance as voluntary behavior.
- This can lead to the misuse of voluntary psychiatric admissions.
Findings:
- Cognitive disorganization fundamentally undermines the capacity for voluntary action.
- The distinction between voluntary and involuntary status is blurred in psychotic patients.
- Existing categories may not adequately capture the nuances of patient consent.
Implications:
- Re-evaluation of criteria for voluntary vs. involuntary psychiatric hospitalization is needed.
- Development of new categories to better reflect patient capacity and consent is recommended.
- Protecting patient rights and preventing the misuse of hospitalization are critical.