Detection of warble tones in wideband noise with and without hearing protection devices

Noise attenuation by linear hearing protection devices (HPDs) is considered to be independent of the environmental noise level. Linearity of HPDs is one of the basic assumptions underlying the Real Ear Attenuation at the Threshold (REAT) method of HPD testing, which utilizes quiet conditions. However, non-linear growth of masking at high intensity levels may result in the effects of HPDs on detection of speech and warning signals being different from those at high noise levels. The purpose of this study was to determine if the non-linear growth of masking can affect detection of warble signals by persons using HPDs in wideband noise presented at the 100 dB(A) level. Audiometric thresholds of hearing of 10 listeners were measured under four experimental conditions: (1) noise off, HPDs off (condition C1); (2) noise off, HPDs on (condition C2); (3) noise on, HPDs on (condition C3); and (4) noise on, HPDs off (condition C4). The results of this study indicate that detection of signals by persons using HPDs in noise < 100 dB(A) can be well predicted from noise attenuation characteristics of HPDs measured in quiet without the need for a correction factor accommodating non-linear growth of masking. This finding has implications for predicting the audibility of warning signals in noise by persons wearing HPDs.